如何回复审稿人意见

如何回复英文论文编辑部的修改意见ResponsetoEditorandReviewer这是我的英文修改稿回复信DearEditor,RE:ManuscriptIDWewouldliketothankXXX(nameofJournal)forgivingustheopportunitytoreviseourmanuscript.Wethankthereviewersfortheircarefulreadandthoughtfulcommentsonpreviousdraft.Wehavecarefullytakentheircommentsintoconsiderationinpreparingourrevision,whichhasresultedinapaperthatisclearer,morecompelling,andbroader.Thefollowingsummarizeshowwerespondedtoreviewercomments.Belowisourresponsetotheircomments.Thanksforallthehelp.Bestwishes,Dr.XXXCorrespondingAuthor下面是如何对Reviewer的意见进行pointbypoint回答：一些习惯用语如下：Revision—authors’responseReviewer#1:Majorcomments1.TherefereecorrectlynotedthatourlanguageaboutXXXwasambiguous.Therefore,wechangedthetextandthefigurestoemphasizethat….Tofurthersupporttheconceptthat,wehaveanalyzed….AsdepictedinSupplementaryFig.S1…2.AssuggestedbythereviewerwehaveemphasizedourobservationsofXXXinresultsanddiscussionsections.Wehaveaddednewfindings(seeabovepoint)inSupplementaryFigS.tosupport…3.Asrequestedbythereviewerwehaveaddedascheme(SupplementaryFig.)thatsummarizes…Minorcomments1.WehaveremovedthewordSUFFICIENTfromthetitle.2.Wehaveaddedandimprovedthescalebarsinthefigure1and2.3.WehaveaddedstatisticstoFig5C.4.WehavecorrectedthetypescripterrorsintheXXXparagraph.Reviewer#2:1.Becauseofthereviewer’srequest,wehaveperformednewexperimentstobetterclarify…ThenewFig.showsthat…Thisfindingsuggeststhat…2.AssuggestedbythereviewerwehaveaddednewdataofXXXtoclarifythepointthat…3.Weagreewiththereviewerthat…Becauseofthereviewer’srequestwehaveusedXXXtoconfirmthat…ThenewdataaredepictedinSupplementaryFig.4.Becauseofreviewer’srequest,wehaveanalyzedtheefficiencyofRNAibyquantitativeRT-PCRtheefficiencyofRNAi.WehavenowaddedthenewpanelinSupplementaryFig.Reviewer#3:1.Becauseofthereferee’scomment,wehavemovedthepanelofFig.5intothenewFigure6andwehaveaddednewexperimentstoaddress….ThenewFig.6showsthat….2.Inresponsetothereviewer’srequests,wehavestudied….ThenewdataaredepictedinSuppplementaryFig.3.Weagreewithreviewerthat….However,arecentpaperhasshownthat….Wehaveaddedthisreferenceandmodifiedthesentencetounderline….4.WehavechangesFigure1withapicturethat….ThepreviousonewastooweekandthegreenfluorescencewaslostduringtheconversioninPDFformat.5.Becauseofreview’srequest,wehavechangedasmuchaspossiblethemagnificationinordertomaintainthesamescalebarbutalsotopreservedetails.6.ThedifferencebetweenXXXandXXXisnotstatisticallysignificant.InordertobetterclarifythisissuewechangedthegraphicsofourstatisticalanalysisinFig.另外一篇5分杂志的回复：1ndRevision–authors’responseReferee#1:WewanttobeginbythankingReferee#1forwritingthat“thefindinginourmanuscriptisgenerallyinterestingandimportantinthefield.”Wealsoappreciatedtheconstructivecriticismandsuggestion.Weaddressedallthepointsraisedbythereviewer,assummarizedbelow.1.Accordingtothereferee’ssuggestion,theexperimentdemonstrating…;inthenewexperiment,thisresultispresentedintherevisedFig.2.Therefereesuggestsdemonstratingthat….ThisexperimentwasperformedinXXXbycomparing…3.Therefereecommentsthatitisunclearwhethertheeffectof….isdueto….Toaddressthereferee’scomment,werevisedFig.anddemonstratedthat….Tofurtherconfirm….TwonewdatahavebeenaddedintherevisedFig.Insummary,theresultsinFig.demonstratethat….4.Thankstothereferee’scomment,thewrongfigurenumberswerecorrectedintherevisedmanuscript.Referee#2:WewanttothankReferee#2forconstructiveandinsightfulcriticismandadvice.Weaddressedallthepointsraisedbythereviewerassummarizedbelow.1.Therefereerecommendstoshow….WeperformedtheexperimentanditsresultisincludedintherevisedFig.2.Accordingtothereferee’ssuggestion,theexperimentsinFig.wererepeatedseveraltimesandrepresentativedataareincludedintherevisedFig.3.Basedonthereferee’scommentthat,echoingcomment#4ofReferee#1,above.Asstatedabove,wehaveincludednewresults,whichinclude:4.Allminorpointsraisedbythereviewerwerecorrectedaccordingly.2ndRevision–authors’responseWewouldliketothanktherefereesfortheirthoughtfulreviewofourmanuscript.Webelievethattheadditionalchangeswehavemadeinresponsetothereviewerscommentshavemadethisasignificantlystrongermanuscript.Belowisourpoint-by-pointresponsetothereferee’scomments.Referee#1:Referee#1requesttwominoreditorialchanges.Bothchangeshavebeenmadeaccordinglyintherevisedmanuscript.Referee#2:WesincerelyapologizetoReferee#2fornotcompletelyaddressingallofthepointsraisedinthepreviousresponse.Wehavedonesobelowandaddedadditionaldatainhopesthatthisreviewerwillbesupportiveofpublication.1.Referee#2requestsevidencethat….Accordingtothereferee’ssuggestion,aXXXassaywasperformedinXXXcellstodemonstratethat….TheresultispresentedinFig.2.Page17,“the”E3waschangedto“an”E3.3.Referee#2askswhether….Wewouldliketonotethatweinvestigated….inourpreviousstudyandfoundnoevidencethat….Therefore,inthismanuscriptwefocusedon….