公共政策网络管理_机制_模式与绩效测度

2008－09-2705JC40831969－。1。。。[1,2]。。Borzel[3]。Luthmann[4]。、[5]。、、、。。、1211．2000932.201701、、、、、、、。、、、、。:D035:A:1672-6162200902-0059-09○○Vol.6No.2Apr.,200959、1。[20]。2。[13]。。[19]。3。。4。。[20]。AgranoffMcGuire[10]、、。、、、、。。3.2[21]1。“”。2“”[15]。AgranoffMcGuire“。”[15]KenisProvan。“”[22]。。[21]。。。。KenisProven[21]、、、、、、、、、。。KenisProvan、、、、2、、、、、1920。1JournalofPublicManagement612。Scharpf[6]O＇Toole[7]。KickertKoppenjan[8]。、、。Klijn[9]。AgranoffMcGuire[10]CollectiveEfficiency、。R．KarlRethemeyer[11]“”、[12]“”－Material－institutionalSocialStructural。BruijnHeuvelhof[1314]。AgranoffMcGuire[15]1GroupProcess。POSDCORB、、、、、、。2Groupware。SharedLearning。“”、[16]。。3。。。4GovernmentAgency。。。5。Legal－rationalAuthority。、、、。6。。。。7。Agranoff。ProvanMilward[1718]。Kickert[1920]。Kickert、1。33.1、、、、。60○○Vol.6No.2Apr.,2009、1。[20]。2。[13]。。[19]。3。。4。。[20]。AgranoffMcGuire[10]、、。、、、、。。3.2[21]1。“”。2“”[15]。AgranoffMcGuire“。”[15]KenisProvan。“”[22]。。[21]。。。。KenisProven[21]、、、、、、、、、。。KenisProvan、、、、2、、、、、1920。1JournalofPublicManagement61。。6。、、、。12347。3.3。MichaelMcGuire[26]。McGuireActivation、Mobilization、FramingSynthesizing。、、。、、。。、。MichaelMcGuire1。。、。。。。。。5、、、23。leadorgatization(networkadministrativeorganization)625。725。、JournalofPublicManagement63、31、2、3、、、。[23]、。。4。、、Constitution5。[24]。。。。。。2008KeithG．ProvanKenis[25]。Provankenis。SharedGovernance。2KenisProvan。21。、、、、、3KenisProvan21。、、、423。62○○Vol.6No.2Apr.,2009。。6。、、、。12347。3.3。MichaelMcGuire[26]。McGuireActivation、Mobilization、FramingSynthesizing。、、。、、。。、。MichaelMcGuire1。。、。。。。。。5、、、23。leadorgatization(networkadministrativeorganization)625。725。、JournalofPublicManagement63。Agronff[40]8。5。。。、、、。、、。、、、、。、。61、。、。2、。3、、、、。、、。4、、、、。、、123412、34123412345839。、JournalofPublicManagement65[27]Community。1。4Marsh[28]“”。。。MarshSmith[2]。。Scholz“”CleanWaterAct[29]。HisahiroKondoh[30]。Zahariadis、[31]OECD13。。、[32-38]Ot=β1S+M1Ot-1+β2Xt/SM3/M4+εt1OtSMM1M3M4Xεβ。、。S、、、。、M2＝M3/M4M2Ot=β1M1+β2M2+β3Xt+εt。、。、。、、、。[39]、、、。。。3.≡≡≡≡≡1.≡≡≡2.≡≡≡≡1[26]64○○Vol.6No.2Apr.,2009。Agronff[40]8。5。。。、、、。、、。、、、、。、。61、。、。2、。3、、、、。、、。4、、、、。、、123412、34123412345839。、JournalofPublicManagement6525PROVANKKENISP．ModesofNetworkGovernanceStructureManagementandEffectivenessJ．JournalAdminis-trationResearchandTheory2008182229－252．26MCGUIRE．ManagingNetworksPropositionsonWhatManagersDoandWhyTheyDoItJ．PublicAdministrationReview2002625599－609．27SCOTTWRMEYERJW．TheOrganizationofSocietalSectorsPropositionsandEarlyEvidenceM//WALTERWPPAULJD.TheNewInstitutionalisminOrganizationalAnalysis.ChicagoUniversityofChicagoPress1991108－140．28MARSHD．ComparingPolicyNetworksM．BuckinghamOpenUniversitypress19989．29SCHOLZJTWangCL．CooptationorTransformationLocalPolicyNetworksandFederalRegulatoryEnforcementJ．AmericanJournalofPoliticalScience200650181－97．30HISAHIROK．PolicyNetworksinSouthKoreaandTaiwanDuringtheDemocraticEraJ．ThePacificReview2002152225－244．31ZAHARIADIS．PolicyNetworksElectionsandStateSubsidiesJ．ReviewofPolicyResearch2005222115－131．32O＇TOOLELJMEIERKJ．ModelingtheImpactofPublicManagementImplicationsofStructuralContextJ．JournalofPublicAdministrationResearchandTheory19999505－526．33O＇TOOLELJMEIERKJ．PublicManagementinInter-governmentalNetworksMatchingStructuralandBehavioralNetworksJ．JournalofPublicAdministrationResearchandTheory2004144469－494．34O＇TOOLELJMEIERKJNICHOLOSON－CROTTY．ManagingUpwardDownwardandOutwardNetworksHierarchicalRelationshipsandPerformanceJ．PublicAdministrationReview20057145－68．35O＇TOOLELJMEIERKJ．NetworkinginthePenumbraPublicManagementCooptativeLinksandDistributionalConsequencesJ．InternationalPublicManagementJournal200693271－293．36MEIERKJO＇TOOLELJ．ManagerialStrategiesandBehaviorinNetworksAModelwithEvidencefromU．S．PublicEducationJ．JournalofPublicAdministrationResearchandTheory200111271－293．37MEIERKJO＇TOOLELJ．PublicManagementandEducationalPerformanceTheImpactofManagerialNetworkingJ．PublicAdministrationReview200363675－685．38MEIERKJO＇TOOLELJ．ManagerialNetworkingIssuesofMeasurementandResearchDesignJ．AdministrationandSociety2005375523－541．39．J．200642107-142．40AGRONOFF．IsManagingWithinIntergovernmentalNetworksChangingtheBoundariesofGovernmentAPreliminaryReportC//PaperPreparedforSecondAnnualFoundersForumAmericanSocietyforPublicAdministration64thNationalConferenceWashingtonD．C．March．2003．、JournalofPublicManagement675。6。1SMITHMJ．PressurePowerandPolicyStateAutonomyandPolicyNetworksinBritainandtheUnitedStatesM.NewYorkHarvesterWheatsheaf1993．2MARSHDSMITHMJ．UnderstandingPolicyNetworksTowardsaDialecticalApproachJ．PoliticalStudies20004814－21．3BORZELTA．OrganizingBabylonOntheDifferentConceptsofPolicyNetworksJ．PublicAdministration1998762253－273．4LUTHMANN．PoliticalTheoryintheWelfareStateM．Trans-latedByBednarzJrJ．Berlin/NewYorkDeGruyter1990．5WITTEJMREINICKBENNER．NetworkedGovernanceDevelopingaResearchAgendaC//PaperSubmittedtothePanelonTheEffectofPublicGovernanceonInternationalRegimesattheAnnualConventionoftheInternationalStudiesAssociationMeetingsNewOrleans200224－27．6SCHARPFFW．InternationalPolicyStudiesIssuesConceptsandPerspectivesM//KENNETHIHFRITZWSC.InterorganizationalPolicyMaking.LondonSAGE1978345－37