对历史学的若干反思-何兆武

,。(Ctes,~haft),(Nat~1lt)。()(Wi*1)t,、;,。,;、(),(),。。,;,。,,,。,;,。,。,,。;。,();,。,。,。“”,,。,,,。,。“”,“”,“”。“”,,。。,。,。;,,。,,,。,。,、,。“”。,(》;,,,:。。,,,:,,。,:,,。,,。,,,,。。,?,,;,。,,。:,,。,`,。,,。:。,。。、。。,(),。。,。。,,。,()》,,,,。,,《),。,,,、、。,。,(,),(kenncl),(wissen)。。(),。,,。,。,,,。,(),·38·,。,,。,。?。,,,,。“”,,。,(“,”)。,,,。,。(),;,、。,。、,,。,。,,。,,,。,;,、。,。,“”、“”、“”、“”,。,“”,()。,,。,,,。。,?,。,()()?,;,,。,,。,。,(Seelensverm6gen)。。·,。,。,;,,。,,。。,,,,。。,,?,?,,(I),(n)()。,(,)。H?,I,。I,、。,,。,11。,I。11,,。;、,。,,;,。,。,。。(),()。“”,,。,,。()(,)。,。,。。I,,,。,,。,n,。,。、。,。,,。。,,。,,,。。,1。,。,·40·`,,。,。,,,。。,,,。,,,,。,,,,。(),。。,。,,,。,。、、,。。,,,,,,。()C`)(),、。。“”。“”。“”,()。11。,。,,、。n,。,。,。。,,。“”,,;“”。,,;,、()。,,“”。,。。、。,。,,。(n)。“”,。,。,。,()。。,。11。,。。,,()。(,。)。,,;,,—,。(、)。“”,。,。,。,、、,,。,、。、。,。(),。();,、、、。,。,。,。“”,,。“”“”,“”“”。,。。。,,。,,。()。,。,,。,,。,。(),。、、。·24·、、。,。,,、。,。,,,。、,。,—。、,,。()。,。,,。???,;,。“”,“”(,,)。,,,,?(porlgeomenon),,,。,、,,,(,、,),。,。,;?,。,,,,;,(),,,。()。,,。,、。,。,、。,。()。,,,。,,(),()。,(),,;()()。,,。(),,n,I。I,n。,。,。。,()。,。,,。,,。()。、、,。,,;,,,,,(“”);。,,,;,,,。(,。),,。——,。,,。,。,;,。(,)51MMARIESOFARTCLESOnhtePa、hofDevdopmentfo、heOirenatlSoicteyZhuZhneTliis15ausmmaryofviewpointssubmittedtothegthNationalSyn1Posiumonhistoriealtheories(Oet.1620,1995,Kunmi).AlotofporblemswerediseussedonSymposiumsuehastheasiatiemodeofporduetion,thedevelopmentofpolitiealsystem,economy,eul-tureoftheorientalsoeieyinaneienttime,therelationshipbetweentraditionandmoderniza-tioninorientalsoeiety,theeities,peasantryandtheintelleetualinaneientorientalsoeiety,thesinologyabroadand50on.IowtoEvaluatetheStudiesofHiistoryofPeasantWarY““anqi,;gTheauthordisagreeswiththeartieie“on`fheHisrotyofThePeasantWat:oSmeGraveMisinterpretations”writtenbyHuangMinlan(“HistoriographyQuarterly”,1995No,4)intheevaluation()fthestudiesofhistoryofpeasantwar.AFewRefleetionsoxiheHistoriographyhZaowz`Thepresentpaperaimstoexlieatewhy15itthathistoryshouldbeand15indeedalways:ewtitten.It15beeausehistoriealdoeumentsorfaetscanneverbythemselvesgiveoutapie-teofhistoryhieh15inthelastanalysisaconstruetionofthehistorian’5mentalitybutnotofmeredata.InohisSense,historiografpy15bothaSeieneeandnotaSeienee(notaSeieneeinthe:ensethatitpossessessomeaspeetswhieharenooeieneeatall),Ieneehistoriographyeonsi:tsoftwolevelsofreseareh:historiograPiy1dealswiththeeriteismofhistoriealdoeu-mentsandfaets(w}liehfallsithintheophereof:eienee)andhistoriography11dealswiti、theunderstandingandexplanationofhistoriographyl(whieh15morehumanistiethan:ei-entificnnat:lre).Chi:laandtheWester:2HistoriealSeienee(Seeondhalfofohe20thCentury)hZangGuangzhiTheartirlemakesaeoneretstudiesofthetrailofthenfluxoftheesternhistoriealseeneeintoChinantheseeondhalfofthe20theenturyandofits:everberationinChina’5aea-demieeireles.This15thesuppleenttoauthor’5lastartivle“ChinaandtheWesternHisto:i-ealSeienee(FirsthalfoftheZOthCentury)”publishedinlastnu:nberofthismagazine.