从克罗马罗依案看国际仲裁裁决的撤销与执行

20025(91)(100872):,,:(ChromalloyAeroServiceInc.v.MinistryofDefenceoftheRepublicofE2gypt),:??,??,,1988616,43200,,,,,,,::,,,,,,199112,,,1992,,,611,1994824(),,,,,1620,,,,199427(),1985(),(4)(6),,,19941028,,1113,1995311995125,,,,JuneGreen1996731,199554,1997114,:,,19975,,,2000,,1995125,,,,,19839,,,19942739123,,,,,;,;,199427531,,711,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,199427531,19941028,,1996731:(),19761603(a),,:(1),,;(2),,,,()9,,31994814,19941028,34(1)(a)4(2)4(1)(b),5(1),,,(e),,,,,,7:,,,811,,,,,():,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,()5(1),,,(may),77,,,,,,,199554,,1997114,(),198233,,,7,1502,19811502911,5(1)(e),:(1),,;(2),;(3),;(4);(5),,,,,()150235,,,,,,,,,,,,(),,,,,,,:,lulv(JanPaulsson),Green,,75,lw,,,lxly,,,,,,,(),,,,021,,,,,,,,lz5(1)(e),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1988,,,,,,,,l{,,,,,,,l|,,,5(1)(e),,,,l},,,,,,,,,,,,,l~,,,,,,121,,,mu2090,,,,,mv2,1999,,mw,,,,;,,,,5(1)(e),,,,:,,(),,,mx,(JudgeHaight),my,(byfreeandinformalarbitraionprobonoetaequo),,,:,5;,,mz,,,,,,,:(pickandchoosepolicy),m{,,,,5(1)(e),,,221,5(1)(may),,,willshall(PieterSanders)60,,,5(1)may,shall,,,(serontrefusees),,mayshall,5(1)maym|5,,,,,9(1)5(1),:,,,m},9(1),,,(internationalstandard)(lo2calstandard)m~5(1)9(1),;,,,,,,nu,,,(),,,nv,,,,,:,321,nw,,,,,,,,,,5(1)(e),,,,,,,,,,,:,;,,nx,,,,1504(1),,,,,?,,:,;,,:,,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,421,,():,(),,,,,,;;;,,:,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,:,,,,:,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,5(1)(e),,521,,,,,,,,,,,,,2080,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,5(1)(e),7,,,,,,,ny,,,500,30,3nz,,n{,,,,,,,,,,,,,621,,,,,,,,,,,,,:YearbookCommercialArbitration,1999,pp.265266;JournalofInternationalArbitration,June1997,No.2,pp.125126,September1997,No.3,pp.142145.lwSeeGaryH.Sampliner,EnforcementofNullifiedFroeignArbitralAwards,JournalofInternationalArbitration,Septem2ber1997,No.3,p.145,p.142.YearbookCommercialArbitration,1999,pp.265268.1985:(1);(2),;(3);(4),;(5),AhmedS.El-Kosheri,TheEnforcementofAwardsNullifiedintheCountryofOrigin,:,1999,545YearbookofCommercialArbitration,Vol.22,1997,pp.10011012,pp.691695.199112,(HilmartonLtd.v.OmniumdeTraitementetdeValorisation)SeeTiborVarady,JohnJ.Barcelo,andArthurT.VonMehren,InternationalCommercialArbitration,WestGroup,1999,pp.788795.luJanPaulsson,RediscoveringtheN.Y.Convention:FurtherReflectionsonChromalloy,12MealeysIntlArb.Rep.(April1997)20,p.30;GeorgesR.Delaume,EnforcementAgainstaForeignStateofArbitralAwardAnnulledintheForeignState,RevuedeDroitdesAffairesInternationales(1997),No.2,p.253.lvEricA.Schwartz,ACommentonChrommalloy,14J.IntlArb.2(June1997)p.125;HamidG.Gharavi,Chromal2loy:AnotherView,12MealeysIntlArb.Rep.(January1997)21.lx19911219HilmartonLtd.v.OmniumdeTraitementetdeValorisation(OTV),OTV,Hilmarton,1988819,,,,19891121,19911219,1990227,19911219,,lyEricA.Schwartz,ACommentonChrommalloy,14J.IntlArb.2,June1997,p.125.lz20016,1262001627A/CN.9/501l{SionSoleimanyv.AbnerSoleimany,(1998)WeeklyLawReports,pp.811-832;YearbookCommercialArbitration,1999,pp.329342.l|1(1),721l}PhiloppWahl,EnforcementofForeignArbitralAwardsSetAsideintheirCountryofOrigin,TheChromalloyCaseRevisit2ed,JournalofInternationalArbitration,1999,No.4,p.137.l~EmmanuelGaillard,EnforcementofAwardsSetAsideintheCountryofOrigin:TheFrenchExperience,InternationalCouncilforCommercialArbitrationCongressNo.9,KluwerLawInternational,1999.muWilliamW.Park,NationalLawandCommercialJustice:SafeguardingProceduralIntegrityinInternationalCommercialArbitration,TulaneLawReview,Vol.63,1989,p.658.mv:,1999,105115,237242mwBakerMarine(Nig.)Ltd.v.Chevron(Nig.)Ltd.F.3d194(2dCir.1999).mxnxnynzSeeAlbertJanvandenBerg,TheNewYorkArbitrationConventionof1958:TowardsaUniformJudicialInterpre2tation,KluwerLawandTaxationPublishers,Deventer,1981.mySpierv.CalzaturificioTecnicaS.p.A.,71F.Supp.2d279(S.D.N.Y.1999).mzDanaH.Freyer,UnitedStatesRecognitionandEnforcementofAnnulledForeignArbitralAwards,TheAftermathoftheChromalloyCase,JournalofInternationalArbitration,No.2,April,2000,p.7.m{HamidG.Chromalloy:AnotherView,MealeysInt.Arb.Rep.January1977,21,p.23.m|m}JacquesWerner,WhereDoYouComefrom,.Arbitration?SomeReflectionsonQuoVadisArbitration?-SixtyYearsofArbitrationPractice,byPieterSanders,JournalofInternationalArbitration,1999,No.4,pp.185186,p.156.m~JanPaulsson,EnforcingArbitralAwardsNotwithstandingaLocalStandardAnnulment(LSA),TheICCInternationalCourtofArbitrationBulletin,1998,May.nuWilliamW.Park,DutyandDiscretioninInternationalArbitration,AmericanJournalofInternationalLaw,1999,Vol.93,p.823.nv,1985nwW.LaurenceCraig,SomeTrendsandDevelopmentsintheLawsandPracticeofInternationalCommercialArbitration,30TexasInternationalLawJournal,Winter1995,p.57.n{GaryH.Sampliner:,,19991821