您好,欢迎访问三七文档
1、TheProblemofSocialCostRONALDCOASERonaldCoaseisProfessorEmeritusatUniversityofChicagoLawSchoolandaNobelLaureateinEconomics.ThisarticleisfromTheJournalofLawandEconomics(October1960).Severalpassagesdevotedtoextendeddiscussionsoflegaldecisionshavebeenomitted.I.THEPROBLEMTOBEEXAMINEDThispaperisconcernedwiththoseactionsofbusiness¯rmswhichhaveharm-fule®ectsonothers.Thestandardexampleisthatofafactorythesmokefromwhichhasharmfule®ectsonthoseoccupyingneighbouringproperties.Theeconomicanalysisofsuchasituat。
2、ionhasusuallyproceededintermsofadivergencebetweentheprivateandsocialproductofthefactory,inwhicheconomistshavelargelyfollowedthetreatmentofPigouinTheEconomiesofWelfare.Theconclusiontowhichthiskindofanalysisseemstohaveledmosteconomistsisthatitwouldbedesirabletomaketheownerofthefactoryli-ableforthedamagecausedtothoseinjuredbythesmoke,oralternatively,toplaceataxonthefactoryownervaryingwiththeamountofsmokeproducedandequivalentinmoneytermstothedamageitwouldcause,or¯nally,toexcludethefactoryfromresiden。
3、tialdistricts(andpresumablyfromotherareasinwhichtheemissionofsmokewouldhaveharmfule®ectsonothers).Itismycontentionthatthesuggestedcoursesofactionareinappropriate,inthattheyleadtoresultswhicharenotnecessarily,orevenusually,desirable.II.THERECIPROCALNATUREOFTHEPROBLEMThetraditionalapproachhastendedtoobscurethenatureofthechoicethathastobemade.ThequestioniscommonlythoughtofasoneinwhichAin°ictsharmonBandwhathastobedecidedis:howshouldwerestrainA?Butthisiswrong.Wearedealingwithaproblemofareciprocalnatu。
4、re.Toavoidtheharmto,Bwouldin°ictharmonA.Therealquestionthathastobedecidedis:shouldAbeallowedtoharmBorshouldBbeallowedtoharmA?Theproblemistoavoidthemoreseriousharm.Iinstancedinmypreviousarticlethecaseofaconfectionerthenoiseandvibrationsfromwhosemachinerydisturbedadoctorinhiswork.Toavoidharmingthedoctorwouldin°ictharmontheconfectioner.Theproblemposedbythiscasewasessentiallywhetheritwasworthwhile,asaresultofrestrictingthemethodsofproductionwhichcouldbeusedbytheconfectioner,tosecuremoredoctoringatth。
5、ecostofareducedsupplyofconfectioneryproducts.Anotherexampleisa®ordedbytheproblemofstrayingcattlewhichdestroycropsonneighbouringland.Ifitisinevitablethatsomecattlewillstray,allincreaseinthesupplyofmeatcanonly1COASE:TheProblemofSocialCostbeobtainedattheexpenseofadecreaseinthesupplyofcrops.Thenatureofthechoiceisclear:meatorcrops.Whatanswershouldbegivenis,ofcourse,notclearunlessweknowthevalueofwhatisobtainedaswellasthevalueofwhatissacri¯cedtoobtainit.Togiveanotherexample,ProfessorGeorgeJ.Stiglerinst。
6、ancesthecontaminationofastream.Ifweassumethattheharmfule®ectofthepollutionisthatitkillsthe¯sh,thequestiontobedecidedis:isthevalueofthe¯shlostgreaterorlessthanthevalueoftheproductwhichthecontaminationofthestreammakespossible.Itgoesalmostwithoutsayingthatthisproblemhastobelookedatintotalandatthemargin.III.THEPRICINGSYSTEMWITHLIABILITYFORDAMAGEIproposetostartmyanalysisbyexaminingacaseinwhichmosteconomistswouldpresumablyagreethattheproblemwouldbesolvedinacompeletelysatisfactorymanner:whenthedamaging。
7、businesshastopayforalldamagecausedandthepricingsystemworkssmoothly(strictlythismeansthattheoperationofapricingsystemiswithoutcost).Agoodexampleoftheproblemunderdiscussionisa®ordedbythecaseofstrayingcattlewhichdestroycropsgrowingonneighbouringland.Letussup-posethatafarmerandcattle-raiserareoperatingonneighbouringproperties.Letusfurthersupposethat,withoutanyfencingbetweentheproperties,anincreaseinthesizeofthecattle-raiser'sherdincreasesthetotaldamagetothefarmer'scrops.Whathappenstothemarginaldamag。
8、easthesizeoftheherdincreasesisanothermatter.Thisdependsonwhetherthecattletendtofollowoneanotherortoroamsidebyside,onwhethertheytendtobemoreorlessrestlessasthesizeoftheherdincreasesandonothersimilarfactors.Formyimmediatepurpose,itisimmaterialwhatassumptionismadeaboutmarginaldamageasthesizeoftheherdincreases.Tosimplifytheargument,Iproposetouseanarithmeticalexample.Ishallassumethattheannualcostoffencingthefarmer'spropertyis$9andthepriceofthecropis$1perton.Also,Iassumethattherelationbetweenthenumber。
9、ofcattleintheherdandtheannualcroplossisasfollows:NUMBERANNUALCROPLOSSPERINHERDCROPLOSSADDITIONALSTEER(STEERS)(TONS)(TONS)1112323634104Giventhatthecattle-raiserisliableforthedamagecaused,theadditionalannualcostimposedonthecattle-raiserifheincreasedhisherdfrom,say,2to3steersis$3andindecidingonthesizeoftheherd,hewilltakethisinto2COASE:TheProblemofSocialCostaccountalongwithhisothercosts.Thatis,hewillnotincreasethesizeoftheherdunlessthevalueoftheadditionalmeatproduced(assumingthatthecattle-raiserslau。
10、ghtersthecattle)isgreaterthantheadditionalcoststhatthiswillentail,includingthevalueoftheadditionalcropsdestroyed.Ofcourse,if,bytheemploymentofdogs,herdsmen,aeroplanes,mobileradioandothermeans,theamountofdamagecanbereduced,thesemeanswillbeadoptedwhentheircostislessthanthevalueofthecropwhichtheypreventbeinglost.Giventhattheannualcostoffencingis$9,thecattle-raiserwhowishedtohaveaherdwith4steersormorewouldpayforfencingtobeerectedandmaintained,assumingthatothermeansofattainingthesameendwouldnotdosomor。
本文标题:社会成本问题-科斯-The-Problem-of-Social-Cost--Ronald-Coase
链接地址:https://www.777doc.com/doc-5740228 .html