群体决策与个体决策过分自信的比较研究

:100628309(2008)0420054205:;(KSCX2-YW-R-130);(NSFC:70671099):(1983-),,,,:,()010-64841536()[e-mail]1,3,2,1(1.,100101;2.,130012;3.,100039):,96:,,:;;;:B849;C934:A11965,Oskamp,,,(overconfidence)Fis2chhoff,SlovicLichtenstein(1977):,,,,[1-2],,,[3]70%,70%,;70%,,,,,,,2006,[4],,,,,,[5-9],,,,??,,,,,1.194200812144©1994-2009ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.(A)(B)(50%-100%):%:(Bias)=(AccurateJudgment)-(PercentageCorrect)[10],,,,,,[11],[12]Liberman,,[13],,,:=-,,,1.2(riskshift),:[14],(groupdecision-making)[15],,[4-8,16,17],,,,,,,,(grouppolarization),,,,[3,18,19],,,,,Stoner[20],,-,,,,,22.1,,,,,,?,,,2.2,:H1;H2,;H3;H433.1101,5,96,5005200812144©1994-2009ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.:,2:3:,4:,,,(,25)5:,()6:,()7:,41t:(M=76.48)(M=71.38)()(t(95)=4.02,P.05),1,t,,0,(1),21tMtdfP40.3320.30950.00038.0318.26950.00041.4325.55950.000t,,4(2);,,3(2)2tMtdfP-2.291.09950.139--3.40-1.82950.035,:,;,,;,5,Hill1982:N+11?Hastie1986,:,[3],Yates[2,21]Yates(argumentrecruitmentmodel),,,,,,,,,,[22],Yates,(3),0,.430,.001,,Lichtenstein15200812144©1994-2009ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.[1]3(PearsonCorrelation)1.000.001.001.00-0.090.43331.000.380.00.:33P0.01,(M=33.34)(M=36.16)(),(t(95)=1.57,P=0.061),,,,,(t(95)=1.82,P0.05),,,,,,,,[2-23],,,:[1]KissingerJA.Overconfidence:AConceptAnalysis[J].NursingForum,1998,33(2):18-26.[2]YatesJF,LeeJW,ShinostukaH.BeliefsAboutO2verconfidence,IncludingitsCross-nationalVariation[J].OrganizationalBehaviorandHumanDecisionProcesses,1996,65(2):138-147.[3].[M].:,2004:190-201.[4],.[J].,2006,14(3):468-474.[5]DarocaFP.InformationalInfluencesonGroupDecisionMakinginaParticipativeBudgetingContext[J].Account2ing,OrganizationsandSociety,1984,9(1):13-32.[6]GalamS.RationalGroupDecisionMaking:ARandomFieldIsingModelatT=0[J].PhysicaA:StatisticalandTheoreticalPhysics,1997,238(1-4):66-80.[7]El-ShinnawyM,VinzeAS.Technology,CultureandPersuasiveness:AStudyofChoice-shiftinGroupSettings[J].InternationalJournalofHuman-com2puterStudies,1997,47(3):473-496.[8]LeaM,SpearsR.Computer-mediatedCommunica2tion,De-individuationandGroupDecision-making[J].InternationalJournalofMan-MachineStudies,1991,34(2):283-301.[9],.[J].,,2005,10(2):25-29.[10]LeeJW,YatesJF,ShinotsukaH,etal.Cross-na2tionalDifferencesinOverconfidence[J].AsianJour2nalofPsychology,1995,1(2):63-68.[11].-[M].1.:,2006:304-310.[12]GigerenzerG,HoffrageU,KleinboltingH.Probabilis2ticMentalModels:ABrunswikianTheoryofConfidence[J].PsychologicalReview,1991,98(4):506-528.[13]LibermanV.LocalandGlobalJudgmentsofConfidence[J].JournalofExperimentalPsychology:Learning,MemoryandCognition,2004,30(3):729-732.[14]MenkhoffL,SchmidtU,BrozynskiT.TheImpactofRiskTaking,Overconfidence,andHerdingofFundManagers:ComplementarySurveyEvidence[J].Euro2peanEconomicReview,2006,50(7):1753-1766.[15]HeathC,GonzalezR.IncreasesDecisionConfidencebutnotDecisionQuality:EvidenceAgainstInformationCollectionViewsofInteractiveDecisionMaking[J].OrganizationalBehaviorandHumanDecisionProcess,1995,61(3):305-325.()25200812144©1994-2009ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.(71),,,,:[1]FreseM,KringW,SooseA,etal.PersonalInitia2tiveatWork:DifferencesbetweenEastandWestGer2many[J].AcademyofManagementJournal,1996,39(1):37-63.[2]FreseM,FayD.PersonalInitiative:AnActivePer2formanceConceptforWorkinthe21stCentury[J].ResearchinOrganizationalBehavior,2001,23(1):133-187.[3]OrganDW.OrganizationalCitizenshipBehavior:ItsConstructClean-upTime[J].HumanPerformance,1997,10(2):85-97.[4]BatemanTS,CrantJM.TheProactiveComponentofOrganizationalBehavior:AMeasureandCorrelates[J].JournalofOrganizationalBehavior,1993,14(2):103-118.[5]FreseM,GarstH.MakingThingsHappen:Recipro2calRelationshipsBetweenWorkCharacteristicsandPersonalInitiativeinAFour-WaveLongitudinalStructuralEquationModel[J].JournalofAppliedPsy2chology,2007,92(4):1084-1102.[6]FayD,SabineS.RethinkingtheEffectsofStressors:ALongitudinalStudyonPersonalInitiative[J].JournalofOccupationalHealthPsychology,2002,7(3):221-234.[7]FayD,FreseM.TheConceptofPersonalInitiative:AnOverviewofValidityStudies[J].HumanPerform2ance,2001,14(1):97-124.[8]SpeierC,FreseM.GeneralizedSelf-efficacyasAMediatorandModeratorbetweenControlandComplexi2tyatWorkandPersonalInitiative:ALongitudinalFieldStudyinEastGermany[J].HumanPerform2ance,1997,10(2):171-192.[9]FreseM,TengE,WijnenCJD.HelpingtoImproveSuggestionSystems:PredictorsofGivingSuggestionsinCompanies[J].JournalofOrganizationalBehavior,1999,20(7):1139-1155.[10]BaerM,FreseM.InnovationisnotEnough:ClimateforInitiativeandPsychologicalSafety,ProcessInnova2tionsandFirmPerformance[J].JournalofOrganiza2tionalBehavior,2003,24(1):45-68.[11]RankJ,PaceVL,FreseM.ThreeAvenuesforFu2tureResearchonCreativity,Innovation,andInitiative[J].AppliedPsychology:AnInternationalReview,2004,53,(4):518-528.[]2008-01-25[]2008-03-10(52)[16]XuZ.InducedUncertainLinguisticOWAOperatorsAppliedtoGroupDecisionMaking[J].