您好,欢迎访问三七文档
当前位置:首页 > 商业/管理/HR > 信息化管理 > How to write a literature__ review
Howtowritealiteraturereview?Howtowritealiteraturereview?Whatisareviewoftheliterature?Aliteraturereviewisanaccountofwhathasbeenpublishedonatopicbyscholarsandresearchers.Occasionallyyouwillbeaskedtowriteoneasaseparateassignmentbutmoreoftenitispartoftheintroductiontoanessay,researchreport,orthesis.Inwritingtheliteraturereview,yourpurposeistoconveytoyourreaderwhatknowledgeandideashavebeenestablishedonatopic,andwhattheirstrengthsandweaknessesare.Asapieceofwriting,theliteraturereviewmustbedefinedbyaguidingconcept(e.g.,yourresearchobjective,theproblemorissueyouarediscussing,oryourargumentativethesis).Itisnotjustadescriptivelistofthematerialavailable,orasetofsummaries.YoucangainanddemonstrateskillsintwoareasBesidesenlargingyourknowledgeaboutthetopic,writingaliteraturereviewlets:informationseeking:theabilitytoscantheliteratureefficiently,usingmanualorcomputerizedmethods,toidentifyasetofusefularticlesandbookscriticalappraisal:theabilitytoapplyprinciplesofanalysistoidentifyunbiasedandvalidstudies.Aliteraturereviewmustdothesethings:beorganizedaroundandrelateddirectlytothethesisorresearchquestionyouaredevelopingsynthesizeresultsintoasummaryofwhatisandisnotknownidentifyareasofcontroversyintheliteratureformulatequestionsthatneedfurtherresearchAskyourselfquestionsliketheseWhatisthespecificthesis,problem,orresearchquestionthatmyliteraturereviewhelpstodefine?WhattypeofliteraturereviewamIconducting?AmIlookingatissuesoftheory?methodology?policy?quantitativeresearch(e.g.ontheeffectivenessofanewprocedure)?qualitativeresearch(e.g.,studies)?Whatisthescopeofmyliteraturereview?WhattypesofpublicationsamIusing(e.g.,journals,books,governmentdocuments,popularmedia)?WhatdisciplineamIworkingin(e.g.,nursingpsychology,sociology,medicine)?Howgoodwasmyinformationseeking?HasmysearchbeenwideenoughtoensureI'vefoundalltherelevantmaterial?Hasitbeennarrowenoughtoexcludeirrelevantmaterial?IsthenumberofsourcesI'veusedappropriateforthelengthofmypaper?HaveIcriticallyanalysedtheliteratureIuse?DoIfollowthroughasetofconceptsandquestions,comparingitemstoeachotherinthewaystheydealwiththem?Insteadofjustlistingandsummarizingitems,doIassessthem,discussingstrengthsandweaknesses?HaveIcitedanddiscussedstudiescontrarytomyperspective?Willthereaderfindmyliteraturereviewrelevant,appropriate,anduseful?Askyourselfquestionsliketheseabouteachbookorarticleyouinclude:Hastheauthorformulatedaproblem/issue?Isitclearlydefined?Isitssignificance(scope,severity,relevance)clearlyestablished?Couldtheproblemhavebeenapproachedmoreeffectivelyfromanotherperspective?Whatistheauthor'sresearchorientation(e.g.,interpretive,criticalscience,combination)?Whatistheauthor'stheoreticalframework(e.g.,psychological,developmental,feminist)?Whatistherelationshipbetweenthetheoreticalandresearchperspectives?Hastheauthorevaluatedtheliteraturerelevanttotheproblem/issue?Doestheauthorincludeliteraturetakingpositionssheorhedoesnotagreewith?Inaresearchstudy,howgoodarethebasiccomponentsofthestudydesign(e.g.,population,intervention,outcome)?Howaccurateandvalidarethemeasurements?Istheanalysisofthedataaccurateandrelevanttotheresearchquestion?Aretheconclusionsvalidlybaseduponthedataandanalysis?Inmaterialwrittenforapopularreadership,doestheauthoruseappealstoemotion,one-sidedexamples,orrhetorically-chargedlanguageandtone?Isthereanobjectivebasistothereasoning,oristheauthormerelyprovingwhatheorshealreadybelieves?Howdoestheauthorstructuretheargument?Canyoudeconstructtheflowoftheargumenttoseewhetherorwhereitbreaksdownlogically(e.g.,inestablishingcause-effectrelationships)?Inwhatwaysdoesthisbookorarticlecontributetoourunderstandingoftheproblemunderstudy,andinwhatwaysisitusefulforpractice?Whatarethestrengthsandlimitations?HowdoesthisbookorarticlerelatetothespecificthesisorquestionIamdeveloping?FinalNotes:Aliteraturereviewisapieceofdiscursiveprose,notalistdescribingorsummarizingonepieceofliteratureafteranother.It'susuallyabadsigntoseeeveryparagraphbeginningwiththenameofaresearcher.Instead,organizetheliteraturereviewintosectionsthatpresentthemesoridentifytrends,includingrelevanttheory.Youarenottryingtolistallthematerialpublished,buttosynthesizeandevaluateitaccordingtotheguidingconceptofyourthesisorresearchquestion.1文献综述的分类根据写作目的和内容的侧重点动态性综述(developmentalreview)成就性综述(resultreview)争鸣性综述(contentiousreview)按时间来划分可分为回顾性综述(retrospectivereview)前瞻性综述(prospectivereview)。根据作者的参与情况,可分为归纳性综述(inductivereview)评论性综述(criticalreview)2文献综述的写作标题与作者(titleandauthor)摘要与关键词(abstractandkeywords)引言(introduction)述评(review)结论(conclusion)参考文献(references)其中最为核心的部分是引言、述评和结论2.1引言(Introduction)两个内容:一是提出问题;二是介绍综述的范围和内容。提出问题时,作者要给出定义性解释、交代研究背景、简单介绍不同文献的看法和分歧所在并介绍该文献的写作目的介绍该综述的范围和主要内容时,作者应使用简明扼要的语句加以概括。引言部分通常为200~300词。引言的内容和结构特点(1)综述的引言通常包括定义性解释、研究背景、现存问题或分歧、综述的目的、内容和范围;(2)使用一般现在时介绍背景知识,使用现在完成时叙述他人成果,使用一般将来时或一般现在时简介本文内容;(3)句子结构力求简洁明了,多用简单句,并列成份较为常见;(4)以第三人称主语为主,间或使用第一人称复数充当主语。表定义或解释①……被定义为……:…isdefinedas…/…hasbeendefinedas…②所谓……是指……:By…ismeant…/By…wemean…③……指的是……:…refersto…④……包括……:…includes…⑤…
本文标题:How to write a literature__ review
链接地址:https://www.777doc.com/doc-4289997 .html